Cookies ‘n Cream Ice Cream Cupcakes

I made these Cookies ‘n Cream Ice Cream Cupcakes with Oreo cookies but they can be made with whatever cookies you choose.

Cookies 'n Cream ice Cream Cupcakes -

Cookies ‘n Cream Ice Cream Cupcakes are so very easy to put together – and you’re going to make every Ice Cream Lover in your life very happy!  (I can’t wait to make these with my grandchildren – speaking of Ice Cream Lovers.)

The east coast of the United States is bracing for a BIG snow storm, arriving here in Massachusetts in a few hours.  I plan to take advantage of being socked in by working on a few new recipes!  I’ve been attempting to perfect a recipe I’m calling Shake, Pour and Bake Pizza Crust.  I’ve prepared it twice so far and the crust is almost right.  Another one or two tweaks and I think I’ll have the results I’m looking for.  In the meantime, both myself and my neighbors are enjoying the results of my ‘pizza crust experiments’.  ; o )

Here’s photos of the two Shake, Pour and Bake Pizzas I’ve prepared so far.  On the left – black and green olives topped with 5-cheese Italian mix.  The 2nd – a Margherita pizza with slices of fresh mozzarella and Parmesan.  (Didn’t have any basil leaves – sprinkled on a bit of fresh Italian parsley.)

small red heart

Here’s how to put-together today’s recipe – Cookies ‘n Cream Ice Cream Cupcakes


  • 1  (1.5 quart container ice cream  (Don’t they sell ‘gallons’ anymore?? )    ++  I used French Vanilla
  • 3 Tbs. chocolate syrup     ++  Optional 
  • 2  (7.5 oz)  containers chocolate shell topping  ++ There’ll be some left over.
  • 3/4 cup Oreo cookies, broken into small pieces   ++  You can use any cookie you chose

METHOD         Line a 12-cup cupcake pan with paper liners

First Layer – Half the ice cream 

Cut the ice cream in half.  Place HALF in a medium bowl.  (Return the rest of the ice cream to the freezer.)  Optional – add 3 Tbs. chocolate syrup and mix to combine.  Drop  1 1/2 Tbs. into each section of the cupcake pan.  ++ Don’t forget to line with paper liners.   ++  Allow ice cream to soften just a bit – it makes it easier to fill the sections.  Freeze ice cream cupcakes for at least 30 minutes.

Second Layer – Warmed chocolate shell topping

Place VERY HOT water in a small bowl.  Stand the 7.5 oz container of chocolate shell topping in the hot water for about 4 minutes.  Squeeze chocolate shell topping over each ice cream cupcake until you have a layer of chocolate topping.  Freeze for at least 30 minutes.  ++  I didn’t warm the chocolate shell topping for this layer – it didn’t spread out very well, as you can see in the photo below.

Third Layer – 1/4 of the rest of the ice cream and 3/4 cup broken up cookies

Briefly chop 6 Oreo cookies in a food processo.  Or – put 6 Oreo cookies in a small baggy and ‘smack up’ up the cookies to break them into small pieces.  You should have about 3/4 cup small cookie bits.   ++  You don’t want ‘cookie dust’, so don’t over do it.

Take out the remaining ice cream.  Remove half the ice cream… in other words,  you only need 1/4 of the 1.5 quart container for this layer. Place ice cream in a bowl, mix in 3/4 cup cookie bits.  Again, the softer the ice cream, the easier it will be to fill each section.  You should have enough for 1 Tbs. in each section.  Smooth ice cream a bit using a spoon. Freeze for at least another 30 minutes.

Fourth and Final Layer – Warmed chocolate shell topping and 1/2 a cookie

—  About 5 minutes before you you’re ready to remove ice cream cupcakes for their final layer, place the 2nd container of chocolate shell topping in a bowl with HOT water.  And – cut 6 Oreo cookies in half to use as a garnish.  ++  The best way to avoid breaking the cookies is to cut straight down with a sharp knife.  I went through LOTS of cookies until I figured that out!

Squeeze warmed chocolate shell topping onto each ice cream cupcake – use enough to cover the layer below .  Gently push a cookie half into the middle of each ice cream cupcake.  Freeze for about an hour.

++  Squeeze the warmed chocolate topping onto only one ice cream cupcake at a time, then gently push in a cookie half.  Otherwise, the chocolate shell on the ice cream cupcakes will be hardened by the time you do the rest.  Guess how I learned that??


++  Adapted from Good Housekeeping – June 2015 

Published by

My Yellow Farmhouse - Cooking with Love!

Sure, it's necessary to eat to survive - but that's not any fun!! The fun comes from cooking, serving and eating with lots of love, I began this blog to share some of the delicious recipes I've gathered over the years. Thanks for dropping by & sharing the love!

15 thoughts on “Cookies ‘n Cream Ice Cream Cupcakes

    1. Bernideen – you are, as I always say, just the sweetest person! Thanks for taking the time to let me know you like my Cookies ‘n Cream Ice Cream Cupcakes! ; o )


  1. I just came back from pigging out on the Southern Style Biscuits I posted this morning with my two guy friends next door. I brought over a basket full of those biscuits – both kinds – and three jars of jam. So darn yummy and so much fun to have enjoyed them with good friends. My kitchen is still A BOMB ’cause I didn’t finish my work on the post until almost 2:00… and now I’m so tired I’m gonna take a nap on the couch AND THEN clean up the kitchen. ++ I would just love it if you lived here in my neighborhood, and my friends Frank and Lad would get a real kick out your sense of humor. (You know, I HAVE gained a lot of weight since I moved here….)


  2. As much fun as I think it would be to live next door to you, Cecile, I know I’d be in serious trouble. There’s a blizzard on the way and you’re baking cupcakes and working on pizza dough. I’d put on 10 pounds before the snow quit falling! I’m going to save this recipe. No, I won’t bake them for myself but I know some serious Oreo lovers. These cupcakes will make the perfect gift. Thanks for sharing!


  3. My kids absolutely love Oreos, and this recipe looks simple and straightforward. We shall try it over the weekend. I’m glad to hear you didn’t get any snow. I saw the huge mounds of snow on Tv yesterday. What a relief for you. Have a great week!


  4. I can’t wait to make these cupcakes with Bella… she is a huge Oreo cookie fan and well, what kid doesn’t like ice cream?
    Plus, I’m excited about the Shake, Pour, and Bake pizza crust recipe… can’t wait for the “final draft” for it. I’ve been dying to start making homemade pizza – an easy crust recipe is just the thing I need to get moving on that!!


    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Sue!!!! Bella will LOVE these!! And she help you make them too. I’d do the first three steps, then let her help you pour on the choc. topping – otherwise the ‘standing time in the freezer’ might be too long for her. She’s sooo cute!!!
      And thanks for your sweet words about the pizza – the crust isn’t a typical pizza crust but its sooooo yummy – and easy!!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s